tieman64
Wim Wenders' "Land of Plenty", a loose sequel to his underrated "The End of Violence", stars Michelle Williams as Lana, a young woman who has returned to the United States after working as a missionary abroad. After leaving behind the war torn borders of Palestine and Israel, she is shocked to find America in a similar state. "Welcome to the hunger capital of America," a pastor, played by "The Wire's" Wendell Pierce tells her, referring to the slums of downtown Los Angeles.Penniless, but armed with her winning optimism and the fearlessness of youth, Lana begins serving the pastor's Mission, helping the poor and handing out food to the homeless. It's a drop in the ocean, but she does it nonetheless.The film takes place in the wake of the 9/11 attacks, and paints a landscape of fear, paranoia, poverty, alienation, misguided aggression, dispossession and hopelessness. While America's war machine – sold to the public as a Christian Crusade - gears up to bulldoze the Middle East, at home people suffer. In this dour world, Lana's character is the only bright light. Contrasted to her angelic, graceful, almost saintly acts, are the actions of her uncle Paul, played unconvincingly by John Diehl. Paul, a symbol of right-wing, warmongering power-figures like Dick Cheney and George Bush, is a Vietnam veteran who spends his days roaming the streets in a surveillance van, illegally spying on others, disregarding murderous Humvee drivers and stalking anyone with a beard. He's an obsessive patriot on a mission from God: to protect the Land of the Free from Ay-rabs and terrorism. At night he has nightmares. Vietnam still scars his psyche.Note that while Paul echoes illegal spy programs like PRISM, MSUCULAR and ECHELON, he also recalls both the "angels" of Wenders' previous films, and the demented national surveillance crews of "End of Violence". It's a neat shift, compassion dovetailing into outright fascism. Regardless, the film draws very simple parallels between Lana and Paul. "Lana has a very innocent, almost childlike faith in God and the power of love," Wenders himself says, "whereas Paul is not really a spiritual person. His religion is America. And America over the last few years has become very similar, in that nationalism has become a kind of religion. It's almost as though Christianity these days can only become defined by certain right-wing politics." So at its core the film is concerned about the perversion of Christian values. Wenders paints a land of plenty where the poor are routinely exploited whilst Christian hallmarks are perverted by administrations to make subjugation, foreign and state-side, all the more palatable. Like Paul, the US sees itself as a country under siege while ignoring all the deeper problems closer to home.Unsurprisingly, the film ends with Lana teaching her uncle to love and let go of his anger, whilst Paul himself must confront the fact that the suspicious "Arabs" he stalks and bullies are just innocent guys going about their business. The film is very very reductive, politically, philosophically and ideologically naive, wrestling superficially with questions greater artists themselves struggle to unravel, but Wenders, himself a devout Christian, seems to know this: "In order to make people identify fully with a character you have to stay in a traditional narrative," he says. "I needed a linear narrative to say what I needed to say in this film." What he's really doing is making a modern version of Dreyer's "The Passion of Joan of Arc", where a young woman's tortured, wide eyed, steadfast faith in God is designed to touch the hearts of we the audience. The film's political baggage and Bush bashing are almost besides the point. Like Dreyer did with Maria Falconetti, the film is designed around Michaelle William's radiant but wounded eyes, and the near-monastic cut of her hair. It's about Williams expressive face, specifically the doubts, fears, loneliness and anxieties hidden almost imperceptibly behind her optimistic outer facade. The question is whether her faith in humanity is enough, whether her radiance will fade with age, or whether, like Joan of Arc, she's destined to be crushed.The film was written quickly, and shot in 16 days on a minuscule budget using the Panasonic DVX100, a cheap digital camera. To date it's the best film shot using the DVX100, a camera which was once touted as the saviour of independent film, before being quickly supplanted by HD. The digital look of Wenders' film creates an intimate, warm environment, as well as a sense of immediacy. Wenders has always been adept at bringing the insights of an outsider to bear on the American experience. "Plenty" echoes some of his previous films - "The American Friend", "Vilence", "The Sate of Things" and "Paris Texas" - but carries with it a greater sense of urgency.8.5/10 – Michelle Williams and the always likable Wendell Pierce turn in very good performances. John Diehl is not convincing, perhaps because his character was conceived as a raging caricature. The film hinges, I think, on a familiarity with Dreyer's "The Passion of Joan of Arc". Ignore the film's politics; it's all about Lana's face. Worth one viewing. Makes a good companion-piece to "Wendy and Lucy" and "35 Shots of Rum".
mule66
I get it the Diehl character is s'posed to be a microcosm of America itself - seeing Arab terrorists under every rock, only to find out at the end that it's his own actions all along that got him into that siege state and truly if he practices good-will to all men everything will be rainbows and lollipops. Sorry Wim you have made amazing movies in the past that stay neutral of the politics and for good reason, polemics are your weak point and they weaken this a well-made, amazingly filmed movie with absurd characters, dialog and plotting. Better luck on your next flick. Another thing that yanked my crank was the belabored point of the homeless section of LA being there for reasons of hunger, these people don't get enough to eat. Truly these folks aren't eating regally but the real hunger these folks is a spiritual hunger, an emotional hunger, a mental hunger. They need self-respect, self-worth, dignity which you can't give a man. Yeah those folks are hungry and if they need it it is available. Less the center for hunger in America, I would say it's more the center for alcoholism, drug-abuse, mental suffering and economic devastation. Dealing with hunger although a noble endeavor is band-aiding a more profoundly systematic societal and age-old human problem of homelessness. Bill Diehl was good though and Michelle Williams was cute as the young yet (cliched) old soul.
matthew
A must-see for anyone who is either a Wim Wenders fan or a person interested in the fears and hopes of contemporary America. German director in a brilliant way makes us ponder upon all the issues so essential to understanding American reality after 9/11. Ethnic prejudices, stereotypes, homelessness,terrorism, Vietnam war, pursuit for an identity, search for lost relatives - all these components are omnipresent, smoothly woven. Wenders mastery reveals in the fact that he manages to touch upon serious topics and in the same time introduce elements of humor and even grotesque. "Land of plenty" leaves us with the voice of Leonard Cohen and plenty of thoughts about relation between individual and contemporary world.
