mark.waltz
Why do people quibble over the alleged sexism, racism and the censorship ripping political correctness of a 70 year old Broadway show and the slightly younger movie version? This is not the history channel presenting the "true" story of the sharpshooting Annie Oakley, but a tall tale based on someone's vision of what would make good entertainment and its investors some money in 1946, greatly increased when MGM bought the film rights. It serves its purpose, just like stories of Calamity Jane and Molly Brown did when they were adapted into musicals. Betty Hutton scored a triumph in 1950, just like Ethel Merman did four years before.Feisty, frenetic and funny, Hutton was an excellent choice to replace the ailing Judy Garland who honestly needed to be replaced because of her personal issues at the time. Hutton, wearing a ton of fake tanning cream, sings the heck out of Irving Berlin and Dorothy Fields' score, perhaps not ideal to her detractors, but celebrated by the public at large who made this her biggest screen success. Howard Keel's Frank Butler may not be an accurate account of the real long time partner and husband of Annie, but serves the role perfectly, appropriately macho when need be, and definitely romantic in his songs.There really is no business like show business, and when it's done right, it can be sensational even when far from perfect. A rousing ensemble opens the film with Keel, Keenan Wynn and Benay Venuta singing of Louis Calhern's colonel Buffalo Bill. Edward Arnold, Clinton Sundberg and J. Carroll Naish also add character to the supporting performances. At times, Hutton seems to be trying to out loud Merman in her singing (having been given the Merm treatment when she played a featured role opposite her in "Panama Battle" on Broadway), but does tone it down in the proper places, particularly "They Say It's Wonderful"). My favorite moment comes with "I Got the Sun in the Morning" which has a very energetic dance. I'm off of my p.c. bandwagon when I watch these old films with long gone ideals that present women as subservient and natives of American soil as savages or full of "ug" and grunts or half sentences. The supporting cast is very funny, the sings and dances rigorous and energetic, and the soft romantic scenes sweet. So I don't take this as definitive, but I'll take what I can get because even with ideals of an era long gone, they have more artistic merit and fun than the agenda driven manipulating dreck of the modern era.
weezeralfalfa
I have fond memories of this film, as it was our senior class play, with a great, but not as great, cast. Not surprisingly, this film version of the Irving Berlin-scored Broadway play of the same title was among the top box office draws of '50, and clearly is the pinnacle of the film career of bombastic star Betty Hutton, although she subsequently was the female lead in "The Greatest Show on Earth", which was voted the Oscar and Golden Globe awards for best film of '52. Initially, there were a number of problems settling on who was going to play Annie, and Buffalo Bill, and who was going to be the director. Judy Garland was slated to be Annie, with Frank Morgan as BB, thus reteaming 2 of the stars of "The Wizard of Oz". In addition, Busby Berkeley, who had directed 3 of the 4 Mickey & Judy musicals was the original director. Well, as it turned out, none of these 3 got very far into making this film. As with the 4th Mickey & Judy musical, Judy clashed with Busby. Hence, it was again decided that he was the more expendable. But, Judy's tardiness continued, thus she was soon fired, as well. Morgan died just as filming was getting underway. Garland's contemplated replacements included Doris Day, Betty Grable, and Betty Hutton: all vivacious blonds, with musical and comedic talent. Unfortunately, all were tied to other studios. MGM was able to strike a deal with Betty's Paramount studios, hence she ended up with the role. DD was greatly disappointed, but eventually was given the consolation prize of "Calamity Jane", with a rather similar role, with Keel again the male lead. This was only Keel's second film role, and his first that featured him singing. He was tall, quite handsome, with a great strong baritone voice, thus scripting Betty to mug insanely when she encounters him in the early going. Keel had had extensive experience starring in some of the top Broadway musicals, including "Oklahoma". Nonetheless, Betty got more of the solos, with them doing several impressive back and forth duets, as in "They Say It's Wonderful" and "Anything You Can Do". In a later interview, Betty reported that most of the MGM crew, including Keel, strongly resented her taking Judy's place and treated her as a virtual outcast, even though at a much later reunion of the surviving cast members, she was praised for her performance. Keel, of course, would go on to star in several additional high profile musicals, including : "Showboat", "Kiss Me Kate", "Seven Brides for Seven Brothers", as well as "Calamity Jane".Your opinion of this film will probably largely hinge on your perception of Betty. Most people seem to either love her or hate her, with few in between. I'm obviously in the first group. This was clearly her masterpiece, not to discount Keel's and Berlin's contributions. Comparing the outtakes of Judy's versions of two of the singing scenes, I hope you will agree that Betty's versions are clearly more interesting, with her exaggerated expressions and mannerisms. Some complain that she grossly overacted. But that was just her style of being funny and dramatic, as is true of most comedians. Some complain about her singing. True, occasionally her voice was too weak, or often included an intentional raucous component, but that was to emphasize her mood or enthusiasm. She could put over rousing songs , like "There's No Business Like Show Business", with great gusto and expressiveness. She could also make weepy ballads sound convincing. One particularly memorable scene has her clownishly imitating Keel's prior "The Girl That I Marry", then dissolving into a weeping continuation of the song, as she compares herself with his stated ideal in a wife. Who else could have done that as effectively?Yes, the 'Indians' were sometimes portrayed as 'wooden Indians' or as howling savages. But, the staid Sitting Bull(the usually humorous J. Carrol Naish), gave her sound advice(and a defective rifle) in her pursuit of Frank Butler(Keel). Some may see the idea that a woman should let her guy feel superior to herself as sexist. But, especially in the times of the real Annie, women were supposed to generally stay in the background. Even today, this is, unfortunately, often sound advice. Ironically, the real Frank Butler was an exception to this rule. Women who are unusually talented or ambitious need to be smart in picking a man who is comfortable in supporting them. Often, an older man(such as Frank), who has already achieved success or fame and is in a position to further her career is the right choice.Of course, as in the case of the '36 "Annie Oakley", considerable liberty was taken with the details of the historical Frank & Annie relationship. For instance, Annie didn't become Frank's stage shooting partner until some years after they married, and they didn't join BB's show until 10 years later! Annie was nothing like the flamboyant Betty, nor Ethel Merman, in the Broadway version!. She was a dutiful conservative Quaker. Actually, BB sometimes also featured another young shooting-trick riding sensation, in Lillian Smith, who much more resembled Betty's version of Annie, in being flamboyant and a flirt!Other films you may enjoy from this era that feature women in traditionally men's roles include: "Comanche Territory", "Against All Flags", "The Ballad of Josie", "Calamity Jane", "Montana Belle",and "Montana"
Scooter B
I love movie musicals - especially when they're done by the Freed unit at MGM. With ANNIE GET YOUR GUN, MGM stayed a lot closer to the source Broadway musical than they usually did. Due to Irving Berlin's sagacious business acumen, there are no major song excisions or substitutions by lesser song writers (Roger Edens, anyone?).As most people know, the role of Annie Oakley was originally assigned to Judy Garland, but when she called out sick, she was unceremoniously fired. Replacing her is Betty Hutton on loan from Paramount Studios. Unfortunately, Hutton mugs and poses and emotes with a frantic, manic energy that I find exhausting to watch. Her Annie Oakley would have fit right in to her film "The Perils of Pauline" portrayal of Pearl White.The rest of the cast is exemplary, with Howard Keel as a handsome, virile Frank Butler. But Betty's shenanigans make her scenes almost painful to watch. The only reason I rate the film as highly as I do is that it's a reasonably faithful rendition of a classic Broadway musical.
