VividSimon Simply Perfect

Smartorhypo Highly Overrated But Still Good

Guillelmina The film's masterful storytelling did its job. The message was clear. No need to overdo.

Kinley This movie feels like it was made purely to piss off people who want good shows

JohnHowardReid The Old Barn Dance (1938), another very good Echo Bridge ex-16mm DVD, release finds Gene Autry actively promoting horses over tractors for farm use. In fact the tractor people are the villains, the cowboys who capture wild horses and auction them at inflated prices to dirt-poor homesteaders, the heroes. At least the story runs unexpectedly true-to-life, even if the script's sympathies are oddly misplaced. Gene carries on as if cowboys are just naturally salt-of-the-earth and that the use of animals as beasts-of-burden is a gift of God, while on the other hand, tractors of course are instruments of the devil. The lovely Helen Valkis and young Sammy McKim help Gene carry on with this illusion - which is not by any means the only odd and inconsistent factor in Bernard McConville's misguided script that admirably succeeds in successfully pandering to rural prejudices.

MartinHafer Like most Gene Autry films, this one follows a standard formula. Gene sings, his backup band sings and Smiley Burnett sings. In addition, Gene retains his squeaky-clean image as an all-around nice guy-- though the ending DID catch me by surprise because instead of shooting the gun out of a bad guy's hand or just punching his lights out, he actually shoots and kills the guy--though he certainly DID have it coming and it was either him or Gene!The film begins with Gene and the boys coming into a town to sell horses at a barn dance they'll put on for the community. Despite all the great singing, however, the residents don't buy a single horse because the town's gone crazy for the new-fangled tractors. Like so many Autry films, this one is set in the present day--with cars, telephones and tractors! Now without income, Gene agrees to bring his musical show to the radio--unaware that the unscrupulous lady in charge of the station will use this to sell MORE tractors. To make things worse, the guy who owns the tractor company is a real creep and intends to foreclose on all the farmers and taking them for everything he can get. When Gene learns he's been duped, he then refuses to make more broadcasts. However, this doesn't dissuade the lady nor the evil tractor salesman and it's ultimately up to Gene and the gang to dispense some good old fashioned cowboy justice.Overall, this is yet another pleasant Gene Autry outing--about average but improved with some nice singing and the violent finale.

dougdoepke Good compact screenplay that manages to coordinate songs, action, and radio-station plot in fairly smooth fashion. Okay, so maybe a tractor can do the work of 5 horses, but can a tractor run down a bad-guy in a car by going overland. Gene shows how a horse can (before Champion). Besides, a tractor can't be stroked or nuzzle like a buddy like a horse can. Actually, the movie somewhat mirrors Depression era conditions (1938)—the farmers owe more on the tractors than they can pay, so they may lose their farms. Trouble is they're the victims of a crooked scheme that involves the unwitting Autry, who then has to make things right. I like the radio programming from behind a bale of hay—a whole new concept in broadcasting. In fact, mobile broadcasting plays an important role in the story. Of course, Frog (Burnette) gets to do his bit, and by playing a musical instrument that looks like it's from Mars. All in all, it's a good little Autry programmer, Gene's last for Republic studios, who soon hired Roy Rogers to replace him. Oh well, I still like horses best.

bkoganbing Gene Autry was one of the most popular of stars in the 1930s and 1940s, in the movies,on radio, and on record. In his own way, a lot like Bing Crosby except he appealed to the folks in what now would be considered the red states.His westerns were primarily musicals and had little plot line. But I have to confess that the villain here was truly unique. Tractor salesmen who are out to takeover a lot of land when farmers put up mortgages to get tractors. Do you believe it? Gene Autry is hawking the virtue of using horses for ranch and farm work and he defeats the dastardly tractor people who have hornswoggled him to do a radio show for them.With that kind of plot, can you take this film seriously. Of course not. So just listen to the singing.By the way, the Old Barn Dance was a popular radio show at the time that featured country and western music and Gene made his start there