VividSimon
Simply Perfect
Billy Ollie
Through painfully honest and emotional moments, the movie becomes irresistibly relatable
mark.waltz
This is more of a musical revue with a slight edge of a plot, and truly enjoyable only when the Andrews Sisters are singing or some well known clowns are providing some dated but still humorous chuckles. Of course, when the Andrews Sisters get loose with "Don't Sit Under the Apple Tree" (with anybody else but me....), it almost tops their performance of "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy" in Abbott and Costello's earlier "Buck Privates", of which this is obviously a low budget follow-up to. Ted Lewis leads the band, and performs "Me and My Shadow" (with a black dancer, of course...), while Shemp Howard and Mary Wickes provide the necessary amount of laughs simply by searching for a table in a nightclub to make this (barely) a passable time filler. Of course, Mary Wickes could flip pancakes and crack jokes in her deadpan manner and she'd steal the show.
Terrell-4
Private Buckaroo, a high-energy, patriotic movie from 1942, has two uses now. The first is to show us the optimism of our elders as they readied themselves to support the troops fighting in WWII. Sure, the jokes are corny, but the musical numbers crank up the confidence with everything from "Don't Sit Under the Apple Tree" to "Six Jerks in a Jeep." It's not a bad idea to now and then remind ourselves of what an older generation of Americans were facing. The second use of the movie is to provide fodder for all those graduate students eager for an easy doctorate in "American Popular Culture," a phenomenon that proves, if the money is right, that American universities will offer degrees in just about anything. The barest of plots has Harry James being drafted. Naturally, his whole orchestra signs up, too, including Lon Prentice (Dick Foran), his singer who has an attitude adjustment problem. We see the high-jinks of training, a romantic encounter that will serve to straighten Prentice out, and a big show just before the boys ship overseas. All this is just a clothesline to pin on at least 13 musical numbers, and The Andrews Sisters and Harry James do most of them. The comedy intermissions are several. To give you an idea of what Universal's writers were capable of, the three-way romantic laugh relief involves Bonnie-Belle Schlopkiss (a tall and emphatic Mary Wickes), Sergeant Muggsy Sharell (Shemp Howard, who was earlier and later became again one of the Three Stooges) and Lancelot Pringle McBiff (an odd incarnation of stand up comic Joe E. Lewis). Personally, I enjoyed most Huntz Hall as a corporal trying to teach James how to play reveille. Although some people today can pass by The Andrews Sisters because of their style, particularly Patty Andrews' mugging, the three were expert at close harmony. They have six numbers; all are skillfully delivered with a great deal of verve. As far as Harry James goes, I can't think of a better way to open a movie than James and Helen Forrest giving us the full treatment of "You Made Me Love You." And in one showstopper we have The Jivin' Jacks and Jills, a group of dancing teen-agers formed by Universal to showcase the studio's young talent. The ten kids tap and leap all over the stage to "Apple Tree." The fact that the story line is almost non-existent and that romantic lead Dick Foran, who sounds a bit like a cross between Nelson Eddy and Dennis Morgan, has the personality of a cardboard box really doesn't matter at all. Doctoral candidates, start writing your dissertation on "The Underlying Significance of B Movies on the Cultural Development of American Civilization During the Formative Years of World War Two, With an Emphasis on the Influence of Teen-Age Tap Dancers on the Defeat of the Axis."
ptb-8
Completely fascinating and in retrospect a bit sad (conveyor belt recruitment) this is a Universal Pictures musical from an innocent age that served as a morale booster for teens........... the musical numbers are good, the cast incredible (Shemp and Mary Wickes play a couple like Popeye and Oliveoil......! yes, true!) and the Harry James music is excellent. I am constantly flabbergasted at silly criticisms of old films that some people write here feel don't fit this century.....these are films from another age with another sensibility and that is part of their interesting charm. The dance number with the Jumping Jacks and Jills is a teen sensation and I defy anyone to not be thrilled (and a bit moved) by the momentary celebration of their dance skill and enthusiasm. Just enjoy an have a great time watching this great film from 1942.......
Nozz
The cardboard comedy and the pencilled-in plot scarcely have a moment to bore you before the next musical number comes along. Some numbers are better than others-- unfortunately, the title song has not aged well-- but the Andrews Sisters make the movie worthwhile. And Harry James reminds us that he wasn't *only* Betty Grable's husband...
