Diagonaldi Very well executed

CrawlerChunky In truth, there is barely enough story here to make a film.

Nayan Gough A great movie, one of the best of this year. There was a bit of confusion at one point in the plot, but nothing serious.

Geraldine The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

George I watched this movie on HBO a couple of months ago. I re-watched it a couple nights later when my wife came in to watch it. She knew I had been moved deeply when I first viewed the movie. I was in Vietnam in 1968. I was a support person and didn't really see that much action. We did get shot at a few times and one time a couple of guys were wounded when our KP shack took a direct hit. The interviews with the filmmaker's mother and the family of his father are gut-wrenching sometimes. But, they always ring true. When the filmmaker finally finds a soldier that served with his dad in Vietnam it really gets heavy. Stories like this can't be made up. Tremendous moving film about one of the many true American "heros". I am looking for this on DVD. Many great moments, a fabulous documentary.

TheGrip I am a Operation Iraqi freedom Veteran and will attempt to produce my own documentary, about the reserve/Guard experience. I'd like to get a copy of this film. I'll probably write a more complete review on what I just finished watching at another time. I'll be thinking about this film for a long time. Every once in a while, I think of my own experiences with many mixed emotions. I always appreciate the time I spend with other veterans. I hope everyone will thank a veteran each and every time they meet one, especially those of the Korean and Vietnam wars, as they were often vilified. Don't ever hate a veteran, but feel free to express your disappointment of world leaders, it's one of the reasons we wore the uniform.

awmiller I just caught this on HBO and was impressed. Rarely do films engage me on such a personal level. It makes you think about war and relationships honestly, unlike shallow, clichéd, crappy war movies. Part detective story, part personal journey, it made me think what it means to be a man, an American, and a child of the Vietnam generation. Although the film takes a pretty neutral position on politics, it also made wonder why we keep making the same mistakes. Why are our young men dieing in a foreign land for a lost cause? In another 30 years, will another young man or woman make a film about their missing parent? My father was also in Vietnam in 1970, and I feel like I have better understanding of my father and the war. I guess the film confirmed what I already knew: I'm a fortunate son.