VividSimon Simply Perfect

Lucybespro It is a performances centric movie

Moustroll Good movie but grossly overrated

Intcatinfo A Masterpiece!

TheLittleSongbird This is one of my personal favourites featuring Jerry as one of the Two Mouseketeers. It is predictable at times, but it is cute and a lot of fun. The animation is detailed, colourful and expressive, and the music is rousing enough for Tom and Jerry, just how I like it. The sight gags are hilarious, and come at a breakneck pace, and the sword play takes me back to the days of Errol Flynn and Tyrone Power and other swashbuckling legends. Tom and Jerry are both great, but Tuffy is absolutely adorable.Overall, this is a wonderful Tom and Jerry cartoon, predictable it is, but it is entertaining as well. 9/10 Bethany Cox

MartinHafer While I am a huge fan of MGM cartoons, in my opinion, there were two things that made them not as successful as the Looney Toons cartoons. First, in a cost-cutting move, MGM took a great quality animation studio and began producing cheaper looking animation starting about 1954. Ultimately, the jaded studio was so cost-conscious that they later fired all their American animators and had the films made in Czechoslovakia--where no one had even seen one of their cartoons! Second, while most people love the violent and over the top antics in the cartoons, MGM also made quite a few cute cartoons that alienated some of the viewers. I definitely dislike the cartoons featuring Jerry's friends, the duck or the little gray mouse, as they are meant to appeal mostly to little kids but adults may find them way too saccharine.This cartoon is another Mouseketeer toon. This time, Jerry is saddled with trying to make the cutesy gray mouse a swordsman in 17th century France. But unfortunately, the little guy stinks...that is until he ultimately (and predictably) proves himself. Ho-hum.

movieman_kev Jerry the Mouse, Tom the cat, and Nibbles the orphan mouse are back in the times of the three musketeers. Nibbles torture Tom unmercifully and also sings. Pretty funny stuff if you ask me. ( of course you didn't ask, but I told you anyway) This short was nominated for an Oscar for best cartoon short subject in 1955, but sadly didn't win. I don't know why, since this short is simply delightful. One of the first Tom and Jerry shorts to be shown in Cinemascope, This hilarious animated short can be found on disc 2 of Warner Brother's 2-DVD Spotlight Collection set.My Grade: A

Robert Reynolds This short was one at least three or four done with a theme of Jerry and Nibbles as "Mouseketeers" and Tom as their principal opponent. They were all good, but this one is the best of them, in my opinion anyway. It plays best with the basic themes of the swashbuckling type of films being parodied with affection here. Nominated for an Oscar, it's an absolute delight. Highly recommended.