BeSummers Funny, strange, confrontational and subversive, this is one of the most interesting experiences you'll have at the cinema this year.

Bergorks If you like to be scared, if you like to laugh, and if you like to learn a thing or two at the movies, this absolutely cannot be missed.

Calum Hutton It's a good bad... and worth a popcorn matinée. While it's easy to lament what could have been...

Fatma Suarez The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

SimonJack This is the second morale film that Universal put out in 1941 as the U.S. was building up its Armed Forces in anticipation of involvement in the war. World War II had officially begun Sept. 1, 1939, with Germany's invasion of Poland. But, Nazi Germany had taken over other countries before then. And, Japan had begun an invasion of China four years earlier. Germany invaded France on May 10, 1940, and Great Britain had declared war on Germany. That was the state of the world a year before "In the Navy" reached theaters in the U.S. It was anyone's guess when America might be drawn into the war. Few people could imagine how that would happen just six months later when the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor.As in "Buck Privates," Bud Abbott and Lou Costello don uniforms of a service to give the folks at home a look at service in the modern Navy, but with their comedy and hijinks added. The movie is built around a plot of an idolized crooner who is tired of the adulation from fawning women. So, he disappears to join the Navy incognito. Dick Powell plays that role nicely as Thomas Halstead. His love interest turns out to be a Paparazzi-type woman reporter/photographer who's trying to get the scoop on where the heartthrob singer has gone. Claire Dodd plays that role well as Dorothy Roberts. Along with Powell's couple of songs, the Andrews Sisters round out the entertainment in this comedy-musical romance. They don't have any hit tunes in this film, but the Andrews Sisters make any film more worthwhile viewing. They have one very different number – a Hawaiian luau song that is set to a swing beat. "In the Navy" doesn't have Bud and Lou in boot camp, but already serving in the Navy. The antics here are aboard ship and when hosting civilians. Bud is Smokey Adams and Lou is Pomeroy Watson. As in most of their films, the comics have some routines that they might have done in vaudeville. The Marx Brothers also did things like that in their movies. In most cases, it provides the best comedy of the films – for those who use this technique. The laughs here come from Lou getting the best of Bud for once. Bud again film-flams Lou in a money sketch. But in another one, Lou and Shemp Howard (as Dizzy) catch Bud in a version of a shell game. Then Lou has a long sketch in which he teaches Bud the basics of math. He can multiply, divide and add to show that 13 times 7 is 28. We also have a very funny sequence of ship maneuvering – naturally, with Lou in charge. But it turns out to be just a dream by Lou – otherwise the Navy wouldn't give its blessing for the film. So, after six years in the Navy, Lou and Bud will see sea duty, being assigned with Tommy to the Battleship Alabama. I suppose Universal wanted to use a fictitious name so as not to embarrass any sailors on a real ship of the time. And, with the Alabama in this film going to Hawaii, this fictitious ship would likely have been at Pearl Harbor when the Japanese attacked it six months later. Perhaps providence had a hand in guiding the naming of the ship in this film. As it turned out, the Navy did later have a battleship named the U.S.S. Alabama. On Feb. 16, the next year, the Alabama was launched at the Norfolk (VA) Naval Shipyard. It first saw duty in the North Atlantic and Baltic Sea area, assigned to the British Home Fleet. Then, in August 1943, the Alabama sailed to the South Pacific. It saw combat in many of the war battles of the Pacific after that and earned nine battle stars It was decommissioned after the war. Since 1964, the Alabama has been in Battleship Memorial Park as a museum on the coast at Mobile, Alabama.Universal made one other movie with Abbott and Costello ("Hold That Ghost") after release of "Buck Privates" in February 1941. But the first film had received a great reception by the public, and the growing world tensions had many expecting the U.S. involvement in the war at any moment. So, the studio rushed the comedy duo and others into production of "In the Navy" and held back release of the "Ghost" until after this one. After "Ghost" they would do one more service film -- about the Army Air Corps. I think it's very interesting to see the scenes in this film of Hawaii. Some more recent books and films about World War II and the U.S. involvement try to give more drama to the Japanese attack of Dec 7, 1941, by saying that most Americans had never even heard of Pearl Harbor. That may be, but anyone who saw this movie, would probably have known about it. And, with the growing public interest in the armed services and the news commentaries about American defense and preparedness, it's likely that many more of the public at least knew that Pearl Harbor was the U.S. Navy base in Hawaii. One other interesting thing about this film is the frequent use of the slang term "gob" for enlisted sailors. One doesn't hear that term much today. I think it was used most often by the British, and apparently by Ameicans around that time. Besides its entertainment value, "In the Navy" is another WWII era film with some historical interest and value.

MartinHafer If you liked Abbott and Costello in BUCK PRIVATES, then boy are you in for a treat. Their next film was less a new film for them but the last film reprised almost exactly--except now they are in the Navy instead of the Army. Once again the boys are in the service and they are supported by the Andrews Sisters--with lots and lots of singing--too much if you ask me. And, the laughs are pretty much the same once again with no major surprises, though some of the routines are pretty cute (such as Costello teaching Abbott math). It's a pretty well-made but very formulaic film. It also wasn't helped by the extensive and silly use of cheap toy models and a romance that comes out of no where for the finale. How much you like the film is strongly dependent on your love for this comedy team. Kids and some adults probably will enjoy it most, while those who hate old movies will probably be bored by the whole thing. Now I know my opinion is probably NOT that shared by many Abbott and Costello fans. I like their early films but really think they suffer some from all that irrelevant music as well as having subplots involving a third party. In BUCK PRIVATES, Lee Bowman often took center stage--here, it's Dick Powell. While both are fine actors, they sure aren't funny and had no place in the film. I want 100% Abbott and Costello in my films--such as ABBOTT AND COSTELLO MEET FRANKENSTEIN or some of their other post-1941 films.

John (opsbooks) Having recently laughed my way through 'Buck Privates' and 'Keep 'em Flying', I was largely disappointed by this navy tribute. 'Hold that Ghost' was literally put on hold in order to speed up the release of 'In the Navy', and it showed, most noticeably in the less than special effects for the final sequence.Dick Powell was a welcome addition to the cast but he really wasn't given much of a chance to show his talents. The songs overall lacked the punch so evident in 'Buck Privates', and later on, in 'Keep 'em Flying'. A fatal error was the so-called romance between Lou and Patty. The lead singer of the Andrews Sisters may have been a great vocalist but she was a woeful actress. Where were you, Martha Raye? My favourite Bud and Lou gag was the 'Sons of Neptune'. With the boys ad-libbing all the way through, it seemed evident that they and the rest of the cast and crew had a great time getting through the sequence. Director Arthur Lubin, according to author Jim Mulholland, began to laugh uncontrollably during this take. An interesting point from the same source - the censor requested the director not show the actual spitting of water into anyone's face.

jimtinder The duo's second service comedy of 1941 is also one of their best films. The humor abounds, especially in the sequence where Costello tries to impress the Andrews Sisters by captaining the ship. The comic highlights of the film are the "Lemon Bit" (watch as the boys try to keep a straight face) and Costello's efforts to get into a hammock.The romantic subplot isn't bad, either, as the always excellent Dick Powell croons his way into Claire Dodd's heart. One may find themself wrapped up in this plotline, unlike most romantic subplots in A&C's films.Funny material, the Andrews Sisters, a decent plot and an appearance by the one and only Shemp Howard make "In The Navy" an A&C treat. 8 out of 10.